969 Bay Avenue, Toms River, NJ 08753
New Listing
$399,000
Property Type:
Residential
Bedrooms:
3
Baths:
1
Square Footage:
2,118
Lot Size (sq. ft.):
17,424
Status:
Active
Current Price:
$399,000
List Date:
3/16/2026
Last Modified:
3/19/2026
Overview
Description
Rare opportunity for experienced investors, builders, or cash buyers ONLY to restore or reimagine this historic property.! Farmhouse colonial on the largest lot on Bay Ave. Huge walk-up attic or potential second floor. No oil tank or well on property. Property is being sold strictly AS- IS. Seller will make no repairs or credits
Large kitchen has been updated as well as primary suite and bathroom. * Please do not knock on sellers door* Property will only be shown on 3/28 and 3/29, no exceptions
Listing Details MLS# 22605883
Contract Info
- List Price/SqFt
- 188.39
- Property Sub-Type
- Single Family Residence
- Sub-Type
- Detached
Location
- House Number
- 969
- Street Name
- Bay
- Street Suffix
- Avenue
- County
- Ocean
- Municipality
- Toms River Twp (TOM)
- Postal City
- Toms River
- State
- NJ
- Zip Code
- 08753
- Area/Section
- Toms River
- Complex/Subdivision
- Toms River
- Directions
- Bay Ave to 969
General Property Info
- Full Baths
- Yes
- Total Baths
- Yes
- Apx SqFt
- 2118
- # Levels
- 2
- Apx Year Built
- 1870
- Garage
- No
- Acreage
- 0.4
- HOA
- No
- Pool
- No
- Waterfront
- No
- Waterview
- No
- Rooms
- 7
- Basement
- Yes
- # Car Garage
- 0
Tax and Legal
- Asmnt - Total
- 396800
- Taxes
- 7753
- Tax Year
- 2025
Remarks & Misc
- Excluded
- personal items
Ownership Type
- Fee Simple
- Yes
More Information
Style
- Historic
- Yes
- Ranch
- Yes
Interior
- Attic - Walk Up
- Yes
- First Floor Bedroom
- Yes
Zoning
- Residential
- Yes
Foyer
- Floor - Wood
- Yes
Lot Description
- Oversized
- Yes
Included
- AC Units
- Yes
Living Room
- Floor - W/W Carpet
- Yes
Water/Sewer
- Public Sewer
- Yes
Kitchen
- Eat-In
- Yes
- Floor - Wood
- Yes
- Granite/Stone Counter
- Yes
Basement
- Bilco Style Doors
- Yes
- Full
- Yes
Great/Family Room
- Floor - W/W Carpet
- Yes
Cooling
- Multi Units
- Yes
Water Heater
- Electric
- Yes
Primary Bath
- Whirlpool
- Yes
Heating
- Baseboard
- Yes
Exterior
- Porch - Enclosed
- Yes
Parking
- Driveway
- Yes
- Oversized
- Yes
Garage
- None
- Yes
Assessment Status
- Assessed
- Yes
Siding
- Aluminum Siding
- Yes
Roof
- Flat
- Yes
- Shingle
- Yes
Management Type
- No Management
- Yes
Property Features
Ownership Type:
Fee Simple
Style:
Historic; Ranch
Interior:
Attic - Walk Up; First Floor Bedroom
Foyer:
Floor - Wood
Living Room:
Floor - W/W Carpet
Kitchen:
Eat-In; Floor - Wood; Granite/Stone Counter
Primary Bath:
Whirlpool
Basement:
Bilco Style Doors; Full
Cooling:
Multi Units
Heating:
Baseboard
Water Heater:
Electric
Exterior:
Porch - Enclosed
Garage:
None
Siding:
Aluminum Siding
Roof:
Flat; Shingle
Parking:
Driveway; Oversized
Included:
AC Units
Zoning:
Residential
Lot Description:
Oversized
Management Type:
No Management
Assessment Status:
Assessed
Listing Office:
Coldwell Banker Realty
Listing Agent:
Cari L Agostino
Last Updated: March - 19 - 2026
The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of the Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®, and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.