Search the Multiple Listing Service (MLS)

73 3rd Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716

$2,400,000

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 6 Baths: 4.2 Status: Pending

Current Price: $2,400,000 List Date: 11/18/2025 Last Modified: 3/27/2026

Overview

Description

Discover an extraordinary living opportunity in the heart of downtown Atlantic Highlands. This 3 family home that was once a thriving church has been transformed into 3 amazing living spaces. The main church with all its preserved character boasts an open floor plan with a sleeping loft; the 2nd unit has 2 BR's and 1.5 baths, the 3rd unit boasts 4 BR's and 2.5 baths; The thoughtful detail in each remodeled space is enhanced with one-of-a-kind finishes plus it boasts a lower level that is ready to make your own. Perfectly situated near the Sea Streak Ferry for an easy commute to NYC, the shops and restaurants along 1st Ave, and the marina too! Whether you're looking to live, invest, or both this home is not to be missed. Call today!

Listing Details MLS# 22534783

Contract Info

Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Sub-Type: Triplex

Location

House Number: 73
Street Name: 3rd
Street Suffix: Avenue
County: Monmouth
Municipality: Atlantic Highlands (ATL)
Postal City: Atlantic Highlands
State: NJ
Zip Code: 07716
Area/Section: None
Complex/Subdivision: None
Elementary School: Atl Highland
Other Elementary: Atl Highland
Middle School: Henry Hudson Reg
High School: Henry Hudson
Other High: Red Bank Cath
Directions: From South: Rt 36 to 3rd Ave. Property is on the corner of 3rd Ave and E. Highland Ave. From North: Rt 36 to 1st Ave jug-handle (first right after the light). Cross over Rt 36 and continue on 1st Ave. Right on E. Highland Ave. Property is on the corner of 3rd Ave and E. Highland Ave.

General Property Info

Full Baths: 4
Half Baths: 2
Total Baths: 4.2
# Levels: 3
# Units/Bldgs: 3
Apx Year Built: 1910
Garage: No
HOA: No
Pool: No
Waterfront: No
Waterview: No
Rooms: 10
Basement: Yes
# Car Garage: 0

Tax and Legal

Asmnt - Total: 257900

Status Change Info

Under Contract Date: 2026-03-23

Style

Custom: Yes

More Information

Zoning

Residential: Yes

Lot Description

Level: Yes

Water/Sewer

Public Sewer: Yes
Public Water: Yes

Floors

Engineered Hardwood: Yes

Basement

Full: Yes

Cooling

Electric: Yes
Multi Units: Yes

Water Heater

Electric: Yes

Heating

Electric: Yes
See Remarks: Yes

Exterior

Stained Glass: Yes
Other: Yes
Porch - Covered: Yes

Parking

Common: Yes
On Street: Yes
Paved: Yes

Garage

None: Yes

Assessment Status

To Be Assessed: Yes

Roof

Shingle: Yes
Tar Roll: Yes

Rooms

Bathroom: Yes
Bedroom: Yes
Dining Room: Yes
Kitchen: Yes
Living Room: Yes

Bathroom Level

First: Yes

Bedroom Level

First: Yes
Second: Yes
Third: Yes

Dining Room Level

First: Yes

Kitchen Level

First: Yes

Living Room Level

First: Yes

Property Features

Style: Custom Basement: Full Floors: Engineered Hardwood Cooling: Electric; Multi Units Heating: Electric; See Remarks Water Heater: Electric Exterior: Stained Glass; Other; Porch - Covered Garage: None Roof: Shingle; Tar Roll Parking: Common; On Street; Paved Zoning: Residential Lot Description: Level Assessment Status: To Be Assessed Rooms: Bathroom; Bedroom; Dining Room; Kitchen; Living Room Bathroom Level: First Bedroom Level: First; Second; Third Dining Room Level: First Kitchen Level: First Living Room Level: First

Room Information

Bedroom Length: 24.33 Level: Second Width: 15.25 Level: Second Remarks: Unit 1 Loft Bedroom Dimensions: 24.33 x 15.25 Kitchen Length: 24.33 Level: First Width: 11.17 Level: First Remarks: Unit 1 Dimensions: 24.33 x 11.17 Living Room Length: 24.33 Level: First Width: 28.58 Level: First Remarks: Unit 1 Dimensions: 24.33 x 28.58 Dining Room Length: 24.33 Level: First Width: 10.75 Level: First Remarks: Unit 1 Dimensions: 24.33 x 10.75 Bathroom Length: 13.33 Level: First Width: 9.90 Level: First Remarks: Unit 1 Full Bath Dimensions: 13.33 x 9.9 Bedroom Length: 12.67 Level: First Width: 15.42 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Primary Bedroom Dimensions: 12.67 x 15.42 Bedroom Length: 10.83 Level: First Width: 13.42 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Second Bedroom Dimensions: 10.83 x 13.42 Kitchen Length: 10.82 Level: First Width: 15.42 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Dimensions: 10.82 x 15.42 Living Room Length: 23.75 Level: First Width: 14.90 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Dimensions: 23.75 x 14.9 Dining Room Length: 13.00 Level: First Width: 15.42 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Dimensions: 13 x 15.42 Bathroom Length: 8.90 Level: First Width: 4.75 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Full Bath Dimensions: 8.9 x 4.75 Bathroom Length: 4.50 Level: First Width: 4.75 Level: First Remarks: Unit 2 Half Bath Dimensions: 4.5 x 4.75 Bedroom Length: 12.90 Level: Second Width: 12.75 Level: Second Remarks: Unit 3 Primary Bedroom Dimensions: 12.9 x 12.75 Bedroom Length: 13.25 Level: Second Width: 12.25 Level: Second Remarks: Unit 3 Second Bedroom Dimensions: 13.25 x 12.25 Bedroom Length: 15.67 Level: Second Width: 12.25 Level: Second Remarks: Unit 3 Third Bedroom Dimensions: 15.67 x 12.25 Bedroom Length: 24.25 Level: Third Width: 15.67 Level: Third Remarks: Unit 3 Fourth Bedroom Dimensions: 24.25 x 15.67

Listing Office: Compass New Jersey LLC

Listing Agent: Jacalyn Grieco

Last Updated: March - 27 - 2026

Broker Attribution: 732-213-6640

The data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the MLS of the Monmouth Ocean Regional REALTORS®, and site contains live data. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.